Skip to main content

City of Monterey · Statewide General Election

Mayor of Monterey

This is one contest. Enter your address to see every race on your November ballot, and keep track of your picks.

On the ballot

This person is Monterey's directly elected Mayor -- one seat on a five-member City Council (the Mayor plus four district councilmembers) that sets the city's budget, land use, and policy, while an appointed city manager runs day-to-day operations. The Mayor is elected citywide (at large) to a 2-year term -- half the length of a district council seat -- so this office returns to the ballot more often than the Council itself.

Two candidates are running for Mayor of Monterey: incumbent Tyller Williamson and challenger Vince Malfitano. Whoever gets the most votes wins outright -- no primary or runoff.

Monterey is a Monterey County city of 30,218 residents (2020 Census) run under a council-manager government: a directly elected Mayor plus four district councilmembers set the budget, land use, and policy, while an appointed city manager runs day-to-day operations. The Mayor is elected citywide (at large) to a 2-year term -- half the length of a district council seat -- so this office returns to the ballot more often than the Council itself.

Williamson has served as Mayor since 2022, re-elected in 2024, after four years on the Council starting in 2018. In June 2026, city voters rejected Measure D, a proposed 0.375% sales tax pitched to fund police, fire, and other general-fund services -- confirming the structural budget deficit both candidates cite as real and recently tested by voters, not just campaign rhetoric. Malfitano is a first-time candidate for Monterey office; his campaign statement argues "our current leadership has failed us" and centers on the city's financial health. He has outraised the incumbent so far this cycle, roughly $23,000 to roughly $9,000, according to Monterey County Weekly's own reporting.

Tyller Williamson

Tyller Williamson is Monterey's incumbent Mayor, first elected to the City Council in 2018 and elected Mayor in 2022 and again in 2024. He works as an HR specialist for the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, focused on labor and employee relations, after more than a decade at the Naval Postgraduate School. He has served since 2022 on the board of the Community Foundation for Monterey County, chairing its Community Impact Investment Committee. If re-elected, Williamson says he will focus on addressing the city's structural budget deficit while maintaining infrastructure, expanding housing opportunities, and supporting local businesses. He holds a bachelor's degree from CSU Monterey Bay and an MBA from the Naval Postgraduate School.

Strengths

A completed term plus a partial second term as sitting Mayor, four prior Council years, and a public-service career in HR/labor relations and community-foundation board work.

Trade-offs

The city's structural budget deficit -- serious enough that the Council put a sales-tax measure on the June 2026 ballot -- persisted through his tenure, and voters rejected that measure.

Keep in mind

Mayor is a 2-year term in Monterey, so whoever wins is back before voters again in 2028 regardless.

Vince Malfitano

Vince Malfitano is a retired dentist who, per his own campaign website, ran a dental practice in the San Francisco Bay Area before retiring and developing assisted-living facilities. His ballot designation is "Retired Business Owner." His campaign statement says "our current leadership has failed us" and that he will "bring the same discipline and accountability to City Hall" that he applied in his career, prioritizing the city's financial health. Public records reported by Monterey County Weekly complicate that pitch: in the 2010s, Malfitano bought two Nevada casinos (the Delta Saloon and Bonanza Saloon) but was denied operating licenses by the Nevada Gaming Control Board, which found he failed to disclose lawsuits, foreclosures, business interests, delinquent tax payments, and tax liens, and cited "employment-related issues" with his assisted-living and dental businesses. Separately, California State Dental Board records from the late 1990s and early 2000s show he was accused of sexual assault by a dental assistant and of inappropriate touching and comments by a patient, and faced gross-negligence allegations from multiple patients; he agreed to a 2001 settlement placing him on 7 years' probation, suspending him from practicing 30 days, requiring community service, and fining him roughly $15,000 in investigative and prosecutorial costs. Malfitano disputes the boards' characterizations but does not dispute that the licensing denial and the settlement occurred, telling Monterey County Weekly by email that "there are decisions from that period that, with the benefit of hindsight and experience, I would handle differently."

Strengths

A business-ownership background across two industries (dentistry, assisted living), and he has outraised the incumbent this cycle, roughly $23,000 to roughly $9,000.

Trade-offs

Denied Nevada gaming licenses over undisclosed lawsuits and tax liens; agreed to a 2001 Dental Board settlement (probation, suspension, roughly $15,000) after misconduct allegations he denies.

Keep in mind

No prior elected office; this is his first run for Monterey city government, and the disciplinary and licensing history above predates this campaign by two decades.

Source review: Very strong (91/100) · 6 cited sources

Official records anchor this contest, with several source types checked for context.

  • monterey.org (opens in a new tab)City of Monterey's own official Elections page (City Clerk) -- the city's functional Notice of Election for the Nov. 3, 2026 General Municipal Election: lists exactly one Mayor (elected at large, 2-year term), one Councilmember for District 1 (4-year term), and one for District 2 (4-year term), then names every qualified candidate with the exact filed ballot designation -- Tyller Williamson and Vince Malfitano for Mayor; Kim Barber and Tom Reeves for District 1; Jeff Whitmoyer, Vicki Nohrden, and Alec Manas for District 2 -- and states nominations for Mayor and District 1 closed Aug. 7, 2026 while District 2's nomination period was extended to Aug. 12, 2026, after which three candidates qualified. Reached via a direct HTTP request (200); the WebFetch tool returned 403 on the same URL.
  • monterey.org (opens in a new tab)City of Monterey's own official "Meet the Mayor and Council" page: full officeholder bios and term dates for all five current members -- Mayor Tyller Williamson (elected to Council 2018, Mayor since 2022, re-elected 2024, term expires Dec. 2026); Kim Barber (District 1, elected Nov. 2022, term expires Dec. 2026); Gene "Gino" Garcia (District 4, appointed Dec. 2022, elected Nov. 2024, term expires Dec. 2028); Jean Rasch (District 3, elected Nov. 2024, term expires Dec. 2028); and Vice Mayor Ed Smith (District 2, elected at large in 2014 and 2018, then by District 2 in Nov. 2022, term expires Dec. 2026). Smith's own history independently confirms the city's shift from at-large to by-district council elections between 2018 and 2022, and his absence from the District 2 candidate roster confirms he did not seek re-election. Reached via a direct HTTP request (200); the WebFetch tool returned 403 on the same URL.
  • web.archive.org (opens in a new tab)Monterey County Elections -- official "Candidate List" page for the November 3, 2026 General Election, reached via a Wayback Machine snapshot captured 2026-08-23 (every direct fetch of the live page returned HTTP 403 this pass, and the WebFetch tool cannot reach web.archive.org this session, so this snapshot was retrieved via a direct curl request instead). Renders the complete per-candidate roster for the City of Monterey: Tyller Williamson and Vince Malfitano for Mayor; Kim Barber and Tom Reeves for District 1; Alec M Manas, Jeff Whitmoyer, and Vicki Nohrden for District 2 -- each with ballot-designation occupation and filed contact information, none marked withdrawn or disqualified, matching the city's own Elections page roster word for word.
  • en.wikipedia.org (opens in a new tab)Wikipedia -- "Monterey, California": council-manager government (a directly elected Mayor plus four district councilmembers), the current officeholder roster, and the city's 2020 Census population (30,218); used narrowly, cross-checked against and superseded by the city's own pages for term lengths and district structure.
  • public.netfile.com (opens in a new tab)A negative-result campaign-finance check for the District 1 and District 2 races: direct Cal-Access filer searches returned only an Incapsula bot-detection challenge page, not usable results, and the City of Monterey's own NetFile public campaign-disclosure portal (public.netfile.com/pub2/?AID=cmo) loaded only an empty single-page-app shell to a direct fetch, its filer data behind a client-side API this pass could not identify. Documents the absence of a reachable financial-disclosure source for these two races, not any candidate's actual finances.
  • montereycountynow.com (opens in a new tab)Monterey County Weekly (montereycountynow.com) -- "In Monterey's election for mayor, challenger Vince Malfitano seeks to unseat the incumbent" (Aric Sleeper, Aug. 27, 2026): profiles both candidates, reports 2026 fundraising of $9,000 (Williamson) versus $23,000 (Malfitano), and documents Malfitano's record before the Nevada Gaming Control Board (denied a license to operate two casinos he'd bought, over undisclosed lawsuits, foreclosures, and tax liens) and the California Dental Board (a 2001 settlement -- following sexual-misconduct and gross-negligence allegations he denies -- that placed him on probation, suspended him 30 days, and fined him roughly $15,000), each drawn from public board records the article cites.

Last updated September 1, 2026.